Conversation of the Week LXV11: Discrimination, and the Use of Racial and Ethnic Slurs in Social Media

December 2, 2013
Written by Connie Cass - Associated Press in
Race Relations
Login to rate this article
High school student Vito Calli, 15, poses for a portrait by his computer, Wednesday, Nov. 20, 2013, at his home in Reading, Pa. In a shift in attitude, most young people now say it's wrong to use racist or sexist slurs online, even if you're just kidding. But when they see them, they don't take much personal offense. Calli, whose family emigrated from Argentina, says people tease him online with jokes about Hispanics, but "you can't let those things get to you."
High school student Vito Calli, 15, poses for a portrait by his computer, Wednesday, Nov. 20, 2013, at his home in Reading, Pa. In a shift in attitude, most young people now say it's wrong to use racist or sexist slurs online, even if you're just kidding. But when they see them, they don't take much personal offense. Calli, whose family emigrated from Argentina, says people tease him online with jokes about Hispanics, but "you can't let those things get to you." Photo Credit: The Associated Press, Matt Rourke.

Most young people say they aren't very offended about the slurs and mean-spirited videos mocking overweight people or gays or blacks that they encounter on social networking sites like Facebook and Twitter.

"You can't let those things get to you," says 15-year-old Vito Calli, an immigrant from Argentina whose online friends tease him with jokes about Hispanics.

In a notable shift, however, young people are coming around to the idea that it's wrong to contribute to this ugly side of the Internet free-for-all, a poll released Wednesday shows.

A bare majority, 52 percent, of people ages 14 to 24 now say it's never OK to engage in discriminatory language, even when it's just among friends who don't really mean it. That's up from 44 percent in 2011.

A stronger majority – nearly 6 in 10 – say using slurs is wrong, even if you say you're "just kidding." Only about half were so disapproving two years ago.

Meanwhile, the share of young people who come across slurs online has held steady, according to the new poll from The Associated Press-NORC Center for Public Affairs Research and MTV.

More than half of young users of YouTube, Facebook and gaming communities such as Xbox Live and Steam say they sometimes or often encounter biased messages.

Teens and twentysomethings say these slurs and taunting images they see online are mostly meant as jokes. The majority say they aren't very offended when they see foul words online for women or gays – or even the N-word for African-Americans.

"Sometimes I make a couple of jokes that might be offensive to someone and I don't even realize it," said Calli of Reading, Pa. "You forget there's a person behind the computer with actual feelings."

Because a friend chastised him, the high school sophomore has tried to stop labeling anything uncool either "gay" or "retarded." He's finding that a difficult habit to break.

Young people say derogatory stuff is most often posted online or texted on cellphones to be funny or cool. Less than a third believe a major reason people use slurs is because they actually harbor hateful feelings toward the groups they are maligning.

Most do see hateful thoughts as at least a minor reason, however.

Some slurs are taken more seriously than others. Racial insults are not that likely to be seen as hurtful, yet a strong majority – 6 in 10 – felt comments and images targeting transgender people or Muslims are.

Almost as likely to be viewed as mean-spirited are slurs against gays, lesbians and bisexual people, and those aimed at people who are overweight.

Maria Caprigno, who has struggled with obesity since childhood, said seeing mean images on Facebook stings. But she thinks the online world reflects the rest of U.S. society.

"It's still socially acceptable to comment on someone's weight and what someone is eating," said Caprigno, 18, of Norwood, Mass. "We need to change that about our culture before people realize posting stuff like that online is going to be offensive to someone."

Graphic shows AP-NORC Center/MTV poll responses to discrimination in social media.

Erick Fernandez of West New York, N.J., says what people share online reflects the influence of song lyrics and music videos and movies. He doesn't approve but feels resigned to it.

"I try to call some of my friends out on it, but it's really to no avail," said Fernandez, 22. "They brush it off and five minutes later something else will come out. Why even bother?"

In the poll, young people said they were less likely to ask someone to stop using hurtful language on a social networking site than face to face.

Alexandria Washington said she's accustomed to seeing men who wouldn't say offensive things to her in person post pictures of "half-naked women in sexual positions," followed by demeaning comments and slurs like "whore" and "ratchet."

"They'll post anything online, but in person it's a whole different story," said Washington, 22, a graduate student in Tallahassee, Fla.

There seems to be a desensitizing effect. Those who report more exposure to discriminatory images and words online are less likely to say it's wrong than those who rarely or never encounter it.

Context is crucial, too. Demeaned groups sometimes reclaim slurs as a way of stripping the words of their power - like the feminist "Bitch" magazine or gay rights activists chanting "We're here, we're queer, get used to it!"

Washington, who is African-American, said on most days she doesn't come across racial slurs on social media. But she stumbles upon bigoted words when race is in the news, such as surrounding President Barack Obama's re-election, and finds them hurtful in that serious context.

Likewise, Calli, the high school student originally from Argentina, said he could stomach almost any name-calling but gets upset when someone uses a falsehood to denigrate immigrants.

Jeffrey Bakken, 23, a producer at a video game company in Chicago, said the bad stuff online, especially slurs posted anonymously, doesn't define today's young people. He says they actually are more committed to equal rights for minorities and gays than previous generations.

"Kids were horrible before the Internet existed," Bakken said. "It's just that now it's more accessible to the public eye."

The AP-NORC Center/MTV poll was conducted online Sept. 27-Oct. 7 among a random national sample of 1,297 people between the ages of 14 and 24. Results for the full sample have a margin of sampling error of plus or minus 3.7 percentage points. Funding for the study was provided by MTV as part of "A Thin Line" campaign to stop digital abuse.

The survey was conducted by GfK using KnowledgePanel, a probability-based online panel. Respondents are recruited randomly, using traditional telephone and mail sampling methods. People selected who had no Internet access were given it for free.

Associated Press Director of Polling Jennifer Agiesta and AP News Survey Specialist Dennis Junius contributed to this report.

The Digital Abuse Study: Experiences of Teens and Young Adults – apnorc.org

Follow Connie Cass on Twitter

Copyright 2013 The Associated Press.

Tags:
Race Relations

Comments

Cyber bullying?

Submitted by CSULBF2013-10 on

Although this topic might be light to others, to some this is an every day battle. Little comments here and there that a person might find funny typically are not involving their own race, gender, religion. It is easy to laugh at something that would not make fun of myself but the larger picture needs to be looked at. There is someone that is going to see it and could take extreme offense to it. Cyber bullying has continued to be a rising issue in today's society with such heavy influence of electronics and the internet. Yes, it is something that younger generations have grown up with but they need to understand that what is posted/typed can come across offensive and hurt someone even if they are not there to witness it face to face. There is no excuse for young lives to be lost simply due to things on the social networking and personal attacks.

bullying

Submitted by STBONF2013-14 on

Comments regarding race, sexuality, religion etc… are very common in todays youth and there is no reason for it. Even if people say that they are just joking there is a system that has created that view. In order for actions regarding this type of language to stop, people need to say something. The worst type of way to perpetuate a system of injustice is passively, we need to actively stand up against this and to try and eradicate the issue

Cyber bullying

Submitted by CSULBF2013-08 on

I'm happy to see this is finally becoming a topic of conversation. Bullying at any level is so destructive to the foundations of our future. It adds walls and limitations to the outlook possibilities for each person exposed. But there is a deep underlying change that happens to a person when they believe there is no reason to be better because everyone will see them as they are described. I know in this day it's not popular to say other people change us but, they do. Online gaming in any fashion in inundated with slurs of every type! It's really disgusting! I challenge anyone to listen to the online slurs and bullying on Wei, Xbox or play station these days! I would like to see some of these areas better regulated, most of the people playing these games are kids between 8-19 years old. Is that what we want our future society to think about other? That's what's some censorship or regulation or what you say needs to be implemented or race change can never happen. If the future has an I censored ability to say what ever they want everyday then what there consequence today? Nothing! They just continue to sear their own mind and the minds of others with continuous hate and defilement! Those are our children and this is our future! Together we all effect each other with every breath!

The Media

Submitted by PARKS2014-12 on

In this day and age with the evolution of social media and the highrise of young stars that are supposed to be "role models" the use of ethnic slurs and demeaning names are being used more and more. Songs on the radio about "big booty hoes" and smoking weed from these so called "stars" is ruining the young kids who's future is our nations future. Yes I do believe that young kids are "getting older" at a younger age and that may have something to do with the evolution of technology. At 10 years old, kids with iPhone's listening to music, watching music videos, and reading about these stars in the press has put in their head that "grow up as fast as you can". I understand that these stars are just trying to live their dream of becoming famous and selling records, movie deals, or clothes, but these young teens see how they act and the age old statement of "Monkey see - monkey do!" comes into play. The use of ethnic slurs in songs and movies has shown kids a negative response to a person's race or ethnicity. African Americans and rap music has a large use of the N-word in their music and in society we say "oh it's okay", since when did it become okay to call another person a demeaning name even if they are the same race? That word was started by slave owners to make slaves sound like property, so if every person on this planet is meant to be "treated as equals" then why is this word still in fluctuation. Our children and our children's children are the future of this nation, but for them to change how we see race and ethnicity in this country is in part our responsibility. They look to us for guidance and we are their role models for life, so the change starts with us.

Not Role Models

Submitted by PARKS2014-16 on

i totally agree with you especially when it comes to using the N-word. i mean when we listen to hip hop songs in this day and age, its not about the struggles of life but rather "bad bitches" and "hustling n****", which really doesn't reflect well to the future generation. and the fact that the n-word is still in play this issue will not stop. No one has the right to use such offensive words not in public or even in the media. Such ignorance just devalues the society

Agreed

Submitted by PARKS2014-26 on

I agree that lyrics of mainstream songs play a big role in how today's youth and young adults behave. These artists are extremely well-known and liked, therefore their fans think it is ok to talk as they sing. I'm hoping to see, in the next few years, some artists emerge that promote positive messages as opposed to derogatory ones.

cyber bullying not to be encouraged

Submitted by PARKS2014-16 on

Although teenagers and young adults may say that being called "fat", "retard" or any other racial slurs doesnt really affect their feeling, i personally think one can only take so much insults and eventually it may affect someone psychologically. Such offenses are probably the reason why we hear suicidal cases of teenagers who were supposedly happy but in the inside they're not. The media itself doesnt really help in solving issues like this. You see in beauty magazines or health magazines which display women in a way that makes the people have the idea of an ideally fit and acceptable body is like that of the magazine. and therefore the society has such ideas instilled in their minds which leads to bullying like calling people "fat". Personally i think the word "fat" should even be allowed to be used.

A personal sense of humor

Submitted by PARKS2014-02 on

I think everyone is being very sensitive about this topic. We all watch YouTube videos and laugh about stereotypes. Everyone has been made fun of at one time or another and there is no group that is exempt from being joked about. If you get upset and angry and take personally everything that is ignorant said by someone else, it is endless and you will be frustrated. There is no reason to get emotional or upset about jokes and like the kid in the article said, don't take it personally. If beauty magazines make you feel bad, stop reading them.