President Obama No Stranger to Fight Against Racial Profiling

July 23, 2013
Written by Josh Lederman in
Feature Stories
Login to rate this article
Young President Obama
Obama led fight against racial profiling long before he became President.In this Nov. 6, 2003 photo of then Illinois State Sen. Barack Obama, D-Chicago, argues during a debate on legislation about immigrant driver's licenses on the Senate floor at the Illinois State Capitol in Springfield, Ill. More than a decade after he helped pass unprecedented racial profiling legislation in Illinois, President Barack Obama efforts as a young state lawmaker offer some of the clearest clues as to how America’s first black president feels about an issue that’s polarizing a nation roiled by the shooting death of black teenager Trayvon Martin. Photo Credit: The Associated Press File, Seth Perlman

WASHINGTON (AP) – Contrary to many of his critics, President Obama is no stranger in the fight against racial profiling. He led the fight to get legislation passed when he served as an Illinois state senator.

In 1999, a fresh-faced senator from the South Side of Chicago heard constituents complain that police were free to pull over drivers because they were black. So Barack Obama proposed a bill to tackle racial profiling. When it failed, he revised it and proposed it again and again.

"Race and ethnicity is not an indicator of criminal activity," Obama said when his bill finally passed the Senate four years later. He said targeting individuals based on race was humiliating and fostered contempt in black communities.

More than a decade later, Obama's efforts to pass groundbreaking racial profiling legislation in Illinois offer some of the clearest clues as to how America's first black president feels about an issue that's polarizing a nation roiled by the shooting death of black teenager Trayvon Martin.

Racial Profiling Begins Early photo

Obama has spoken only rarely about his own experience with incidents he perceived to be race-related. In his 2006 book "The Audacity of Hope," he described his struggles with the injustices of "driving while black" and the vigilance he felt was still necessary for him and his family. "I can recite the usual litany of petty slights that during my 45 years have been directed my way: security guards tailing me as I shop in department stores, white couples who toss me their car keys as I stand outside a restaurant waiting for the valet, police cars pulling me over for no apparent reason," Obama wrote.

While Martin's family has said the teenager was racially profiled, race was barely mentioned during the nationally televised trial. Now that the state trial is over, the Justice Department is looking into Martin's death to see whether civil rights charges can be filed. Federal prosecutors would have to show evidence Zimmerman was motivated by racial animosity to kill Martin.

The president, in a reflective statement on last Friday about the history of racial profiling in this country and the injustice that has resulted because of it, looked to the future, urging Americans to ask themselves how such tragedies as the Trayvon Martin-George Zimmerman tragedy can be prevented.

One can argue that President Obama has focused more on gun control than issues like racial profiling. But as a young state senator, he and a few colleagues led a fight to require police to keep track of the demographics of drivers they pulled over – race, gender and age – then have those records analyzed to root out any patterns of bias. Diversity training was also part of the package, and another bill Obama pushed sought to prevent wrongful convictions by requiring police to videotape interrogations for crimes like homicide.

Emil Jones Jr., the state Senate's president at the time, said he told Obama he was counting on him to shepherd the profiling bill, part of a broader judicial overhaul involving death penalty reform that Jones said was his top priority. "It called on him to work with legislators on both sides of the aisle," Jones said in an interview. "There was strong opposition from law enforcement on these issues. He was skillful enough to be able to get them on board."

Police Officers Making An Arrest

One of Obama's key arguments to woo skeptical police groups was to say his legislation could actually exonerate fair-minded officers. Those unjustly accused of racial profiling would, for the first time, have evidence to show that wasn't the case. Both the racial profiling and videotaped interrogations bills eventually passed through the Legislature in 2003.

When it first became law, the data showed blacks and other minorities were being pulled over about three times as often as whites, said Craig Futterman, who sits on the statewide panel that oversees the law. These days, it's down to about twice as often, he said. "The fact that this data was being collected and monitored actually dramatically reduced racial profiling in Illinois," said Futterman, a professor at the University of Chicago Law School, where Obama once taught. "It didn't eliminate it - there are still unacceptable racial inequalities."

In the Zimmerman case, civil rights leaders say Zimmerman racially profiled the unarmed teenager when he followed him through a gated community and shot him. But Zimmerman says Martin physically assaulted him and he shot the teenager in self-defense.

But across the U.S., as rallies crop up filled with protesters demanding justice for the teenager whose quest to buy Skittles ended in death, it's not clear what steps the administration may take in the coming months. "I don't have any process to announce today going forward," said Jay Carney, Obama's spokesman. He noted Obama's work on the issue in Illinois and said Obama "believes it's an issue worthy of consideration and action."

AP researcher Monika Mathur contributed to this report.

Reach Josh Lederman on Twitter.

Copyright 2013 The Associated Press.

Obamaonracialprofiling1.jpg35.69 KB
Feature Stories